Sandpaper was a dumb idea but it’s just as bonkers to claim most didn’t know

FILE PHOTO: Australia captain Pat Cummins during a press conference in Sydney on November 13, 2026, following allegations by former player Usman Khawaja on the 2018 ball-tampering scandal REUTERS/Jeremy Piper/File Photo
Australia captain Pat Cummins during a press conference in Sydney (Credits: REUTERS)

Is this a classic instance of a cover-up causing greater collateral damage than the original crime? Which in case you missed it was ball tampering by Australia during the Cape Town Test against South Africa in 2018.

Back then, three Aussie players fessed-up to altering the condition of the ball illegally, in this case by using sandpaper one of them had concealed within their cricket trousers. But Usman Khawaja, a member of that team, and perhaps more crucially with a new book to sell, has outed the entire team as being in on the ruse which, lest we forget, Australia lost comfortably after being rumbled on day three.

Sports teams have shifting codes of honour depending on how players feel they have been treated by them. Back in 2018, the grim trio – captain Steve Smith, David Warner his deputy and willing stooge Cameron Bancroft – dutifully took the rap.

They were severely punished, too, by Cricket Australia, with year-long bans for Smith and Warner and nine months for Bancroft. All three were given 100 hours of community service. Smith and Warner were also barred from any leadership roles for two years.

For an old bowler like me, ball tampering is one of those transgressions where the moral outrage from media and public exceeds the seriousness of the act which, let’s face it, has been going on since cricket’s beginnings on the chalky uplands of southern England 250 years ago. Using sandpaper, though, was a dumb idea given the televisual scrutiny modern teams are under. Equally bonkers to me is the claim that most of the team knew nothing about it, though I must emphasise that remains their case.

It’s unthinkable to me that the bowlers accepted mass abrasions appearing on the ball without question. I say that because to gain reverse swing requires a whole team effort. For it to work, one side of the ball needs to become rough and dry while the other is kept smooth and polished. Sweat is applied to the latter side but no moisture, even clammy palms from fielders, must get on the rough side.

That only three people knew of the ruse seems utter nonsense and Cricket Australia (CA) must have had at least some misgivings.

BRISBANE, AUSTRALIA - DECEMBER 02: Usman Khawaja during an Australia nets session at The Gabba on December 02, 2025 in Brisbane, Australia. (Photo by Chris Hyde/Getty Images)
‘All of us’ knew about the ball tampering plan, says Khawaja (Picture: Getty)

Yet it was obviously expedient for them to accept there were only three bad apples. That way they could contain the damage. Also, any sanctions handed down would not decimate the team.

Ask Metro


Use AI to go deeper into the stories you care about – powered by Metro and trusted publications.

Their actions looked tough but according to Khawaja, who was never spoken to by CA, they did not investigate thoroughly.

This has left current captain Pat Cummins with a bit of a dilemma. Choosing his words carefully (top-notch lawyerly advice) he says Khawaja is ‘100% wrong’ and it is ‘complete and utter nonsense’ to claim that others in the team knew sandpaper was used.

Cummins’ denial then prompted Bancroft to publish a 4,000-word testimony saying that not only did Cummins and the other team members know that sandpaper was being used, they’d seen and admired its effects in the previous Test and that there had been celebrations after two days over how effective it had been in getting the ball to reverse-swing.

To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web
browser that
supports HTML5
video

Cummins responded by maintaining his previous denial. Looking at the scorecard from that match in Gqeberha, South Africa were 183 for six on day two but recovered to add another 200 runs for the last four wickets, so the celebrations were short-lived especially when South Africa won by six wickets. 

But then Australia did take the second new ball just before the close on day two, which would have negated any efforts to make it reverse-swing for at least 25 overs.

Aussies fetishise the Baggy Green and the cultural code of ‘Mateship’ with its values of loyalty and mutual trust. But that seems to have broken down as eight-year-old porkies come bubbling to the surface. Ball tampering does that, it makes sensible people irrational.

Although I felt the original outcry in 2018 to border on the hysterical, I must confess to enjoying the sense of schadenfreude as they tear each other’s reputations apart.

The only shame is that this gilt-edged publicity for Khawaja’s book is wiping England’s 2-1 victory over Australia in the ODI series off the back pages.

Still, we shouldn’t complain. The view from Blighty is that it’s all win-win Down Under at the moment.

Sandpaper was a dumb idea but it’s just as bonkers to claim most didn’t know

#Sandpaper #dumb #idea #bonkers #claim #didnt